What is intelligence?
Ways of Being: Beyond Human Intelligence, by James Bridle (2022, Farrar, Straus & Giroux), and Planta Sapiens: Unmasking Plant Intelligence, by Paco Calvo and Natalie Lawrence (2022, The Bridge Street Press)
As the poet and visionary William Blake wrote:
‘The tree which moves some to tears of joy is in the eyes of others only a green thing that stands in the way.
Some see nature all ridicule and deformity… and some scarce see nature at all.
But to the eyes of the man of imagination, nature is imagination itself.’
James Bridle (p. 16; 2022, Farrar, Straus & Giroux)
In the last bit of research I did for my final project, an exciting new way of looking at intelligence is proposed by James Bridle in his book, Ways of Being. He explains that much of the science of studying intelligence in non-human beings, has until recently been flawed by human-centric bias. By measuring other animals abilities to solve puzzles, scientists have wrongly measured intelligence according to human perceptions of how it should be defined. Instead, recent science is revealing that the ‘more-than-human’ have experiences of their own, unlike ours, and that for them, intelligence could mean something different that we can’t fully grasp, a wholly subjective experience of the world.
“To think against human exceptionalism requires us to think outside and beyond it, and to recognise in Blake’s vision the deep truth of his words: nature is imagination itself. In this truth is encapsulated the philosophy behind the phrase I used earlier: the more-than-human world.”
James Bridle (p. 17; 2022, Farrar, Straus & Giroux)
In Planta Sapiens, a book I have recently started, Paco Calvo reveals through studying plants, that he is able to demonstrate to the public that plants respond to anaesthesia and go to sleep, just like an animal or human would. He then posits the question, does that mean they are normally awake? He suggests that each plant has an individual experience of the world, as they can move to follow the sun, and even predict its position the following morning. Does this mean they are aware? If this is true of the smaller plants he studies, I wonder what it might mean for giant ancient trees. After all, in Suzanne Simard’s work I studied last year, the ground-breaking scientist who revealed that trees can communicate via underground mycorrhizal networks, if her science has only recently come to the fore, what else might we discover?
“We are so entrenched in the dogma of neuronal intelligence, brain-centric consciousness, that we find it difficult to imagine alternative kinds of internal experience.”
Paco Calvo, (p. 3; 2022, Bridge Street Press)
The Forest and the EcoGothic
How and why have forests been depicted as dark, scary places for so long? This book has the answers, and shows the way to move forward…
“Robert Harrison, in his seminal work Forests: The Shadow of Civilisation (1992), mourns the widespread loss of our connection to the woods, arguing that we now see them as mere setting and resource. We have largely lost the ability, it seems, to see them as truly strange, monstrous, and enchanting.”
Elizabeth Parker, The Forest and the EcoGothic: The Deep Dark Woods in the Popular Imagination (p. 5; Palgrave MacMillan, 2021)
On my trip to photograph Sherwood Forest, due to the historical and mythical tales of Robin Hood, and also as one of the largest collections of ancient oaks in Europe, I started reading The Forest and the EcoGothic, and it had a profound effect, particularly on my vision for my final project. It seemed to be exactly what I was looking for.
In this book, which focuses on the darker, scarier side of depictions of forests, Elizabeth Parker reiterates some of the points Harrison made in Forests. Parker says that people's fascination with the romanticised concept of forests reflects their sense of loss and the significance of forests to them, and is symbolic of a variety of emotions and situations, including danger, renewal, and bewilderment. She explains the literature on forest mythologies is vast, and Gothic depictions of forests in stories may be the result of innate fears and fears created in stories. During environmental crises, Parker argues for seeking out ‘Gothic Nature’, as well as ‘Romantic Nature’, because it brings an important darkness of nature worth embracing.
When I started reading this, I had just taken some shots that would open up a new way of portraying trees to me, that fit in superbly with the Gothic and Romantic, by evoking the ‘sublime.’
“In a broader sense, The Forest and the EcoGothic significantly examines our representations of and relationship to nonhuman Nature. It does so in a time when understanding—and questioning—this relationship is more vital than ever before.”
(p. 3; Parker, 2021)
Going back to the Dark Ages
How far back does the separation from civilisation and forests go? I delved into the Dark Ages and beyond to fine out…
The Real Middle Earth by Brian Bates, The Anglo-Saxons by Marc Morris, Beowulf: A New Translation by Seamus Heaney, and Forests: The Shadow of Civilization by Robert Harrison
I read J. R. R. Tolkien’s epic trilogy of The Lord of the Rings the previous summer. At the time, I was curious about what locations near me he was influenced by in creating Middle-Earth, and thought it would be a fun landscape photography project. When I came across Brian Bates' The Real Middle Earth, it discusses the historical sources that Tolkien drew from and his ideas for his fictional natural landscapes, such as Mirkwood, Lothlorien, and Fanghorn, which were inspired by ancient forests like the great Andredesweald that were seen as sacred groves and the homes of potent spirits by the people who lived there. This led me to want to understand more about that time, so I found The Anglo-Saxons by Marc Morris.
Morris paints a brutal picture of the land that eventually became England, after the fall of the Roman Empire, and the gradual taking over of the land by Anglo-Saxon colonists, often by force. In this lawless time, the strongest and often meanest clans became local, then regional powers, eventually leading to the first kingdoms. It was around this time that the epic old English poem Beowulf was written, and is used by Morris as one of his more accurate depictions of Anglo-Saxon life, despite it also containing fictional monsters.
As a Professor of Anglo-Saxon at Oxford, Tolkien also studied Beowulf, and I was intrigued by what this story said about nature. Although the story links the habitats of the monsters with the wild, and that they are beast-like creatures that eat people, the story itself appears more about the struggle of power, suggesting the beast within man. The linking of nature to danger and evil, suggests a Christian influence, but it may also be a reflection of the mindset of those who lived in perilous times.
“In the history of Western civilization, forests represent an outlying realm of opacity which has allowed that civilization to estrange itself, enchant itself, terrify itself, ironize itself, in short to project into the forest's shadows its secret and innermost anxieties. In this respect the loss of forests entails more than merely the loss of ecosystems.”
Forests: The Shadow of Civilization, Robert Harrison (preface; University of Chicago Press, 1992)
I’ve only scratched the surface of this book by Harrison, but it appears he was interested in something similar to what I wanted to find out, why had the forest been depicted as a scary place so many times in different cultures? Especially when my own experiences of them had been calming, even therapeutic, and places of beauty. Further discoveries in research and practice led me to deeper thought on this matter, and how it could be reframed.
Looking for inspiration: Part 2
England on Fire: A Visual Journey Through Albion’s Psychic Landscape, is a stunning piece of curation from Stephen Ellcock.
After seeing In The Black Fantastic next door, I wandered into the Haywood Gallery shop and had a browse. I spotted this book, now one of the best art books I own, and immediately it felt entirely relevant for my research and also a complete joy in its diversity and depth of content. These are just a handful of artists I found through this book, named in the captions when you view full size. They each seemed to fit the mood I wanted to go for, having long been interested in wooded scenes in moody low light. I have since followed Stephen Ellcock on Facebook, where he regularly posts evocative discoveries, and have since collected his next book, The Cosmic Dance, proving himself to be a hot curator to follow.
Inspiration from fiction
“The forest itself looked tangled, dense and hostile; I could see away across the foliage tops, and they were unbroken, a sea of grey green, rippling in the wind, looking almost organic, a single entity, breathing and shifting restlessly beneath the unwelcome aerial gaze.”
- Mythago Wood, Robert Holdstock (p107; 2014, Gollancz).
Mythago Wood, a fantasy novel by Robert Holdstock, delves into the idea of mythic archetypes and the human ability to create.
The story's protagonist, Steven Huxley, returns to his childhood home in England after his father's death.
He learns that Ryhope Wood, not far away, is a place where myths and legends come to life, and he is dragged into a journey to learn about and face the formidable and potentially dangerous forces at work in the wood.
During the course of the journey, he faces his own personal demons and learns about the deep connections between his family, the forest, and the fantastical creatures who call it home.
I found this story an engaging one, certainly strange in places but deliberately so. For me, it was as much about discovering the wild within and having connotations of the ‘Green Man’, as it was about the wooded environment. I look forward to reading the second book in the series. The mystical aspect reminded me of some of my childhood experiences playing in woods in Wales, where I spent some of my youth growing up.
“He dreamed that a tree was growing at the foot of his bed and filling the sky. He started to climb, using the giant fissures in the bark as hand and footholds. As he looked up, he saw the canopy was ablaze with lanterns and laden with flowers. They drew quickly nearer as he climbed, though the tree was very tall, so that soon Kenelm had reached the uppermost bough and was crawling along it to find a seat among the flowers. Never before had he seen anything so grand and perfect as the tree in which he was sitting. And when he looked ahead, he recognised the hills and rivers of his kingdom opening out before him: Gloucestershire, Worcestershire and Warwickshire and beyond, all within his view.”
Storyland, Amy Jeffs (p212; 2022, Riverrun)
Storyland by Amy Jeffs is a book that delves into British myths and legends from ancient times to the Norman conquest. It follows the stories of giants, heroes, kings, queens, saints, monsters, and magic that shaped British identity and culture.
In the Beginning, Prehistory, Antiquity, and the Middle Ages are the four sections of the book. Amy Jeffs retells several stories in each section with her own style and imagination. The book also includes Jeffs' linocut prints, which depict some of the scenes and characters.
Of particular interest for this project, was the depiction of a huge tree in Kenelm’s dream, based in Winchcombe, just a short journey from my home in Gloucestershire. I’d have to find a local tree that could match the description! Amy Jeffs next book, Wild, should be even more relevant for my project, a continuation of her writings but related to depictions of nature.